WR you say?

[ice grillin you]

heres the list of free agent wr's this offseason...subject to change of course...and igy's official take on each

1)David Givens NE - Complementary guy
2)Reggie Wayne Ind - potential #1...potential peerless price
3)Josh Reed Buf - garbage
4)Randy Hymes Bal - backup
5)Antonio Bryant Cle - backup
6)Antwaan Randle El Pit - versatile and good hands, solid #2/3
7)Eric Moulds Buf - #1
8)Joe Jurevicius Sea - #2
9)Peter Warrick Sea - KR
10)Jabar Gaffney Hou - meh, drops a lot
11)Rod Gardner Car - worth a flier
12)Corey Bradford Hou - #2/3
13)Kevin Johnson Det - #3/4
14)Peerless Price Dal - useless
15)Dez White Atl - maybe a 3/4 guy...but hasnt done much
16)Koren Robinson Min - KR/2/3 if hes no longer insane
17)Quincy Morgan Pit - meh...good if you have 2 or 3 other guys
18)Az-Zhair Hakim NO - done
19)Tim Carter NYG - dont know enough
20)David Boston Mia - done
21)Ike Hillard TB - nearly done
22)Troy Brown NE - backup/lockerroom guy
23)Tim Dwight NE - KR/backup
24)Jerome Pathon Atl - finsished
25)Charles Lee Ari - who?
26)Marc Boerighter KC - random white guy #4 receiver
27)Reggie Swinton Ari - useless
28)Troy Walters Ind - ick
29)Patrick Johnson Bal - inactive for 14 of 16 games

RFA's

1)Brandon Lloyd SF - decent...makes crazy catches...drops easy ones
2)Patrick Crayton Dal - dont know enough
3)Nate Burleson Min - didnt pan out this year...needs more development
4)Eddie Drummond Det-KR - strictly KR
5)Kevin Walter Cin - backup right now
6)Shaun McDonald Stl - meh
7)Willie Ponder NYG - meh
8)Kevin Curtis Stl - real solid 3/4
9)Kelley Washington Cin - maybe a 2/3
10)David Tyree NYG - meh
11)Derick Armstrong Hou - meh
12)Kaseem Osgood SD - maybe a 3
13)Arnaz Battle SF - good 2/3...good special teamer as well...which many wrs wont/dont/cant do
14)Chris Horn KC - maybe a 3/4
15)Bryan Gilmore Mia -

[mussa]

Randle fargIN EL gets me excited.   

He versatile, fast as shtein and has proved to be a solid receiving threat.  A receiver that can throw and return punts.  I say we pick up him and Reggie Wayne and clear shop.

[Philly_Crew]

I agree with most of your "takes".  The RFA's are not significantly better than the UFA's so I wouldn't bother with any of them.  Moulds or Randle-El. 

[BigEd76]

Jurevicius won't come here because we made fun of his dead baby.

[rjs246]

Jurevicius won't come here because we made fun of his dead baby.

And rightfully so. Stupid baby.

[ice grillin you]

Jurevicius won't come here because we made fun of his dead baby.

that was like three years ago

[Wingspan]

Randle fargIN EL gets me excited.   

He versatile, fast as shtein and has proved to be a solid receiving threat. 

um....where exactly has he proven this??

he's never finished in the top 10 in any major category. has 1 100 yard game in his career, and has never started for a full season.

randel-el is nothing more than this years Az-Hakim...he is nothing.

[ice grillin you]

i was surprised to see antonio bryant had a 1000 yard season in 05

still not sold as he is a little mental...but at the right price he is mos def someone to look at

[rjs246]

Randle El is a good receiver on a team that never passes the ball (and when it does pass the ball it has tunnel vision focused on Ward). Saying he's never been in the top 10 in any category is one of the most worthless tidbits to throw into the conversation.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

i was surprised to see antonio bryant had a 1000 yard season in 05

still not sold as he is a little mental...but at the right price he is mos def someone to look at

Bryant's a very good player.  The Eagles were scared away from him in the draft due to character issues, though.


At least he'd give a CHANCE to improve the WR corps if he was signed.  I want either him, Moulds, Wayne, or Randle-el.

[Wingspan]

Randle El is a good receiver on a team that never passes the ball (and when it does pass the ball it has tunnel vision focused on Ward). Saying he's never been in the top 10 in any category is one of the most worthless tidbits to throw into the conversation.

he's never been more than a #3. and i dont see anything to convince me that he'll be a #1 or #2 anywhere else.

[BigEd76]

I know he's mostly known for the one-handed catches, but Lloyd put up decent numbers for a brutal offense.  I think the Eagles originally passed on him in 2003 because of character issues though...

[SunMo]

he's never been more than a #3. and i dont see anything to convince me that he'll be a #1 or #2 anywhere else.

well i'm sold.

[MURP]

I'll take Moulds, Givens, Wayne, Jerkinvicious, Randle El, Bryant.  Not obtaining one of these is a failed WR offseason.

edit: as far as UFA goes.

[MDS]

Is Moulds a full-fledged ufa? I thought he was going to get released because of the problems in Buffalo. If so, he would be the best fit. He's in the kind of spot in his carrer where he would sign for less money here for the chance to win. not saying thats gonna happen, just thinking out of the "top" guys on the market, he would be the one to lean that way. you figure wayne will take the best deal out there, since this is his best shot at a mega deal. givens could do the same or he could go back to suck of brady and billicheck with everyone else in bastohn.

im all for moulds. but for not too much. a healthy mcnabb, improved reggie brown, returning stinkston, etc. are semi decent for offense. this team has loads of problems on both lines, at linebacker and at fullback. id much rather see those problems get fixed than break the bank on wayne or moulds. good thing andy thinks that way, too.