Why Peyton Is A Fraud

[Rome]

why did mcnabb's name get brought up in this thread anyway?  it has nothing to do with him.

Because certain people enjoy bashing him no matter what the circumstance.

They're called hungry hungry hippos for a reason, bro.

[Rome]

you wanna know one of the biggest chokers from yesterday?  how about Nick Harper?  how his ass got tackled by a QB, I'll never know.

Roethlisberger had a shiv and wasn't afraid to use it, beyotch.

[JTrotter Fan]

Peyton Manning = slightly less than Dan Marino

He may throw up a lot of stats, but he won't win a Super Bowl.

[MadMarchHare]

Again, Tony farging Dungy.

How many times this guy been in the playoffs?  With 1 WIN TO SHOW FOR IT??!!

And we bash Reid - Jesus.  And before you get on my sack IGY, Tony lost plenty with TB as well as Indy.

[ice grillin you]

who said dungy was a good coach...hes on par with reid as far as im concerned...both should be coordinators



Because certain people enjoy bashing him no matter what the circumstance.
They're called hungry hungry hippos for a reason, bro.

might wanna recheck the thread dook...first five people that brought up mcnabb were groupies trying to use mannings failure as a way to make themselves feel better about mcnabbs own inability to come up large in big games

[bobbyinlondon]

Again, Tony farging Dungy.

How many times this guy been in the playoffs?  With 1 WIN TO SHOW FOR IT??!!

And we bash Reid - Jesus.  And before you get on my sack IGY, Tony lost plenty with TB as well as Indy.

Dungy is 4-7, I believe--

In '99, he lucked out against the Skins when they had a bad snap on a GW FG; then they lost 11-6 to the Rams (1-1)

The next two years, he lost one game where he was favored (Eagles) and they got demolished in his last game (1-3)

In his first playoff game with Indy, they got beat by a Jets team that made the playoffs on the last Sunday of the regular season 41-0 (1-4)

The next year, they beat Denver and the Chiefs, but got waxed by the Pats (3-5)

Last season, they again waxed the Broncos, but only scored 3 against the Pats (4-6)

And yesterday's loss, when THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE THEIR YEAR (4-7)

[Wingspan]

mcnabbs own inability to come up large in big games

and the only "big games" are the ones the birds lost?

the 7 playoff victories are meaningless right?

[ice grillin you]

ok...championship games

[Wingspan]

he played poorly in 2 of them. one you can look at injury considering he didnt finish the game.

but i would say he came up pretty big in the games vs the falcons and the first one vs the rams.

[SD_Eagle5]

Every playoff game is a 'big game'. In the playoffs give me the guy who can get it done (McNabb 7-5) with mediocre talent vs. the guy (Manning 3-6) with superb talent around him. What has McNabb had to work with? TO for 1 game (the SuperBowl). Westbrook for the first time last season. He's had nothng while Manning had two great receivers, good TE, great RB, good defense, were at home.

And to quote John Fox: "Stats are for losers"

[Wingspan]

thats still 3 more conference champ games than manning has gotten too.

[ice grillin you]

mcnabb did it in the nfc...in the afc hes not sniffing any championship games

he should have been in two or three superbowls by now...not losing to jake delhomme  and brad johnson

and ive heard the 102 reasons (aka excuses) why he hasnt won a superbowl...so you can save those

[Geowhizzer]

who said dungy was a good coach...hes on par with reid as far as im concerned...both should be coordinators



Because certain people enjoy bashing him no matter what the circumstance.
They're called hungry hungry hippos for a reason, bro.

might wanna recheck the thread dook...first five people that brought up mcnabb were groupies trying to use mannings failure as a way to make themselves feel better about mcnabbs own inability to come up large in big games

IGY, you were one of the "first five." Are you a McNabb groupie? 

I am a McNabb fan, as he is an Eagle and a class act.  Is he infallible?  No.

BTW, you still haven't put in your list of what QBs you'd rather have right now.

[SD_Eagle5]

mcnabb did it in the nfc...in the afc hes not sniffing any championship games

he should have been in two or three superbowls by now...not losing to jake delhomme  and brad johnson

and ive heard the 102 reasons (aka excuses) why he hasnt won a superbowl...so you can save those

The AFC has not been that great the past 5 seasons. Nobody thought the Pats had a chance vs. the Rams in 01'. The Bucs absolutely destroyed the Raiders in 02'. Carolina took the Pats to the edge. And we very well could have beaten the Pats last season (none of the AFC teams were even close)

[hunt]

in the 4 nfc championship games plus the super bowl...mcnabb has thrown 6 td's and 8 int's.