Why Peyton Is A Fraud

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

yesterday manning was under ridiculous pressure and still threw for almost 300 without a pick

You know that's bullshtein.

[ice grillin you]

so now we do stats on what should have happened not what really did?

pretty much any replay judgement that we deem wrong should not count??

alstott against the skins earlier in the year didnt get in the end zone...so really the skins won that game...correct?


where does it end

how about if manning floated an interception into someones chest and they drop it...should that count as an int too since the db should have caught it?

[PhillyPhreak54]

My whole thing is that you can't say that McNabb would've looked bad yesterday just because it was Pittsburgh and he looked bad against them a year ago. Donovan wouldn't have been a statue in that pocket for the STeelers to tee off on. He might not have run it, but he has more pocket elusiveness than Peyton. So who is to say that Donovan wouldn't have had some success.

One thing that is different is that the Eagles probably would've had a lot of 3-step drop stuff to help offset the rush. As well as screens and things of that nature. But the Colts were running a lot of 7-step drop stuff and that played right into the Steelers hands.

[MURP]

yesterday manning was under ridiculous pressure and still threw for almost 300 without a pick.

lol, yeah on the final stat sheet.  But anyone who watched the game knows Troy Polamalu had a legit INT and was a hair away from picking off a few more.  Lucky Manning.  You watched the game, Manning threw a bunch of terrible throws that could have been picked.  Dont pretend he was throwing great passes under pressure all day. 

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

My point, IGY,  is that you said "without a pick" as if it were a big accomplishment for Manning being under pressure all day, but as MURP said, he was throwing garbage and taking sacks all day, just like any QB would be... and the Polamalu overturned INT is only one of his many zesty throws.

[hunt]

22-38 with 290yds, 1 td and zero picks isn't bad...the only real screwup by manning yesterday was his post game comments bashing his o-line, imo.

[PhillyGirl]

22-38 with 290yds, 1 td and zero picks isn't bad...the only real screwup by manning yesterday was his post game comments bashing his o-line, imo.

Holy shtein hunt, if you're fishing quit it. I can't imagine you actually watched this game and you're serious with this post.

[chuck_chillout]

You watched the game, Manning threw a bunch of terrible throws that could have been picked. 

Manning doesn't throw picks, his receivers run bad routes.

[MDS]

Uhhhh...he put up 18 points. And he was so lucky to get the last 8 of em. I don't care what his stats say. He sucked yesterday.

[hunt]

22-38 with 290yds, 1 td and zero picks isn't bad...the only real screwup by manning yesterday was his post game comments bashing his o-line, imo.

Holy shtein hunt, if you're fishing quit it. I can't imagine you actually watched this game and you're serious with this post.

those were his numbers...i didn't make them up if that's what you're asking.
it's not like manning singlehandedly blew the game...pitt's D had a great day.

[SunMo]

22-38 with 290yds, 1 td and zero picks isn't bad...the only real screwup by manning yesterday was his post game comments bashing his o-line, imo.

Holy shtein hunt, if you're fishing quit it. I can't imagine you actually watched this game and you're serious with this post.

those were his numbers...i didn't make them up if that's what you're asking.
it's not like manning singlehandedly blew the game...pitt's D had a great day.

no, it's all Petyon's fault, it's Peyton's fault the defense gave up 14 quick points, it's Peyton's fault that Vanderchoke kicked the ball sideways....

christ, these Peyton haters are just as bad as the Donovan haters

[SunMo]

you wanna know one of the biggest chokers from yesterday?  how about Nick Harper?  how his ass got tackled by a QB, I'll never know.

[henchmanUK]

you wanna know one of the biggest chokers from yesterday?  how about Nick Harper?  how his ass got tackled by a QB, I'll never know.

I can see why he might have been slowed up.

[mussa]

if he would of cut right instead of left he would of been gone.  LACES OUT!!

[stillupfront]

22-38 with 290yds, 1 td and zero picks isn't bad...the only real screwup by manning yesterday was his post game comments bashing his o-line, imo.

There are three kind of lies:

Lies

Damn Lies

Statistics