Go on the record - Who is your starting QB?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

seven for eight in the red zone for vick

not scores....touchdowns

But per the naysayers, those were against inferior and/or unprepared opponents and have absolutely no bearing on his play against good opponents.  By the way except for maybe the Giants, the critics will claim that every defense the Eagles face for the rest of the season sucks.  So get used to it.

[ice grillin you]

maybe im wrong but i seem to recall the eagles having red zone problems against every defense over the last years

[SD]

seven for eight in the red zone for vick

not scores....touchdowns

And no picks, red zone or not.

The Titans were there for the taking, someone needed to step up and take it, Kolb didn't. I don't think he played poorly - especially since he had no Jackson, the O-line was awful for half the game, and Celek is terrible this year - but Vick has shown the ability to extend plays, take them in using his legs etc. He does what he needs to to score TDs. Kolb reminds me too much of McNabb last season in the red zone.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Speaking of McNabb, he is still generally playing like absolute ass.

[ice grillin you]

Speaking of McNabb, he is still generally playing like absolute ass.

he was so awful yesterday

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

17/32, 200 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT, 2 fumbles (neither lost)
Also, he tacked on -2 yards rushing on 5 carries


So, my analysis at this time is...
Vick > Kolb >>>>>> McNabb

[SD]

Just to be sure I double checked the Bears roster, Ronde Barber doesn't play for them.

[Munson]

-2 yards on 5 carries sounds like a couple kneel downs to me, but i didn't watch


otherwise, what a horrible line. How the farg did they win that game?

[ice grillin you]

17/32, 200 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT, 2 fumbles (neither lost)
Also, he tacked on -2 yards rushing on 5 carries


So, my analysis at this time is...
Vick > Kolb >>>>>>K. Detmer>>>> McNabb

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Just to be sure I double checked the Bears roster, Ronde Barber doesn't play for them.

Check for Ricky Manning Jr.

[mussa]

Vick has been consistent. Kolb on the other hand has shown once this year that he can be dominant and in the other games, pretty much looked sub par or plain bad.  Most of this has to do with what the oline is doing that game and of course the defense. I'm not saying Vick isn't going to have a bad game, I can pretty much bet he's going to suck it up bad at least once in the future. So will Kolb and he'll have great games...It just silly to try and predict the future on this one. Vick is starting so deal with it. I never thought for a minute Vick would amount to anything but he has and I'd much rather watch him make plays than see Kolb running for his life. The team needs a god damn online before Kolb can amount to anything. Let Vick play, I'm all for it, he's entertaining me at this point.

[smeags]

Speaking of McNabb, he is still generally playing like absolute ass.

he was so awful yesterday

wait, are you talking shtein about a game the skins won ?

[ice grillin you]

Speaking of McNabb, he is still generally playing like absolute ass.

he was so awful yesterday

wait, are you talking shtein about a game the skins won ?

no....talkin bout the qb

but you knew this

[MDS]

where are the 5 people who were begging for an extension and crying that the sky was falling cause their precious little bitchface mommas boy qb was traded now?

show yourselves. your boy is finished as if we didnt know that 2 years ago.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Phreak, Retard, PG

There.  That's the list.