It's time for Reid to GO!!!!!!

[SunMo]

What he said.  Name one available head coaching candidate who has had more consistent success than Reid.  Not one superbowl win - better record and better playoff success for more than 2 years.

so that means you actually think Andy Reid is a good football coach?

[ice grillin you]

STATUS QUO

What he said.  Name one available head coaching candidate who has had more consistent success than Reid.  Not one superbowl win - better record and better playoff success for more than 2 years.

first of all ff was being facetious i think...or at most he was saying what he thinks will happen...he wasnt saying he wanted reid to stay

second of all if andy reid was a better coach hed have the one superbowl you so easily dismiss...how can you ask someone to name a better coach and then throw out winning a superbowl as criteria

btw reid is 32-35 since all those playoffs you are so happy about

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

first of all ff was being facetious i think...or at most he was saying what he thinks will happen...he wasnt saying he wanted reid to stay

Correct.

[ice grillin you]

What he said.  Name one available head coaching candidate who has had more consistent success than Reid.  Not one superbowl win - better record and better playoff success for more than 2 years.

so that means you actually think Andy Reid is a good football coach?

he has no idea all he knows is that andy made the playoffs a bunch of times...which even his biggest haters acknowledge is impressive...at the same time you have to understand the game beyond wins and losses to recognize how good a coach is...brian billick won a superbowl

[Stallworth Supporter]

Mike Martz?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Mike Martz?

Go farg yourself.

[Cerevant]

I don't think Andy is a good coach, I think he is a successful coach.  There is no one who is not emotionally attached to this team who thinks that this coaching staff needs to be scrapped.  I've been on the Andy must go bandwagon for quite some time, but I know that it isn't going to happen.  The only hope of this happening is the mental breakdown that he might just be suffering.

I believe that a major change is the only hope for this team to win a Super Bowl.  Unfortunately, while it is a necessary condition, it is not a sufficient condition - it is much more likely that a coaching change will drive this team further down than taking it to new heights.  This is why Lurie and Banner will not pull the trigger on a regime change - it will cost them too much money if they fail.

[ice grillin you]

i dont think theres anyone who believes that lurie/banner will fire reid

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

i dont think theres anyone who believes that lurie/banner will fire reid

Correct.  He will have to resign voluntarily.

[MDS]

i dont think theres anyone who believes that lurie/banner will fire reid

no doubt. banner is safe too. he walks around the novacare like he owns the place.

loyalty and trust are great things to have, but clearly jeffy is blinded by it here. sort of like ed snider and all those years with clarke, cept he kept firing the head coach.

[Butchers Bill]

Passing when trying to run out the clock...check.

Stupid play calling...check.

Total lack of emotion from the team...check.

Refusal to run the ball at critical times...check.

[rjs246]

So everyone is on the Fire Andy Reid Bandwagon now right? There aren't any stragglers who have somehow missed the writing on the wall are there?

I can't begin to imagine a coach who could consistently do worse, when play-calling matters most, than Andy Reid.

[MDS]

Yea America's father of the year was pretty brutal, again. The only good thing about this is my fantasy team moves into #1 rooting priority.

[Butchers Bill]

I don't know if anyone can defend him at this point.  I'd be curious to see an agrument for him being the Eagles HC at the end of the season.

[The BIGSTUD]

The front office won't fire him so it is moot. He is only gone if he resigns.