Grade FA after Runyan signing

[SunMo]

if they let Runyan go and had Herremans or Andrews starting at tackle next year, they would be worse off from last year.  as it is, they signed an important part and maintained continuity at that position.  try and explain what's wrong with that logic.

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

if they let Runyan go and had Herremans or Andrews starting at tackle next year, they would be worse off from last year.  as it is, they signed an important part and maintained continuity at that position.  try and explain what's wrong with that logic.

What's wrong is you can only grade the offseason based on moves actually made.  So, you should have graded them as if they hadn't re-signed Runyan before today and now grade them as if they have... because that's actually what happened and shtein.

Are you going to grade their draft a B- right now?  Because that would make as much sense as grading free agency based on events that have not yet occurred.

[SunMo]

ok, that so my logic doesn't make sense for the flagy letter grade system, ok that's fair.

but my main point is still the same

[ice grillin you]

ok, that so my logic doesn't make sense for the flagy letter grade system, ok that's fair.

but my main point is still the same

make everyone happy and bump em up a half grade and move on....thats what i did

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

Your point is the same as mine, only I did it properly... giving the team a grade in the D range before re-signing Runyan and now upping it to a C when they did re-sign him, because now the offseason is averagish and before it was not.

Try to keep up.

[SunMo]

no, and if i keep catching static from deez cats, i'm gonna fail them alltogether, and nobody wants to go to summer school

[Rome]

I'm dropping my grade down to a "C" so I can be like the "cool" kids on CF!

[SunMo]

that won't help

[Wingspan]

you're right. this sucks.

F

[SunMo]

but sarcasm aside, what's been so great about this offseason?  they upgraded at DE.  they barely upgraded at WR and backup TE.  they also got embarassed by their main target and they had no backup plan.

[ice grillin you]

my thing is he wasnt gone before he resigned....he was in limbo...so their grade shouldnt have been hurt because he wasnt resigned...it should have taken a big hit had he left tho...and stayed the same/slight bump if he returned

[Feva]

I gave 'em a C+ before resigning Runyan... and now that they have I feel better, but I still don't have that feeling of a B this FA period.  Too many slipped through the cracks.

C++

[terpseagles]

I give this offseason the finger.

For now anyway.  Maybe tonight after 12 beers, it'll be a C..... or something.

[SunMo]

i used to know that language

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

but sarcasm aside, what's been so great about this offseason?

Nothing.  That's why I gave it a C.  Averagey McAverageriffic.