New guy evaluations

[stillupfront]

How do you think the new starters are doing so far?

Patterson = Simon
Andrews< Mayberry
Lewis> Pinkston
Brown>>> Mitchell
LJ = Chad

[Don Ho]

Great observations.  I do believe Andrews wil get it all together by mid-season and be an absolute beast.

Very impressed with the backups!  Reno made me very happy. 

[WEST is GOD]

LJ is better than Chad so far, Andrews is the same as Mayberry, Lewis is worse than Pink and Reggie is way better than Freddie.

[Don Ho]

LJ is better than Chad so far, Andrews is the same as Mayberry, Lewis is worse than Pink and Reggie is way better than Freddie.

Oh my

[stillupfront]

, Lewis is worse than Pink

Lewis doesn't become invisible like Pink.

[WEST is GOD]

Something you disagree with or are you so impressed?

oh and as of right now Patterson is doing more than Simon.

[Sgt PSN]

Andrews = Mayberry  (This is only temporary until the young guy gets a few games under his belt)
Patterson slightly> Simon (He showed up to camp and is in shape.  For that reason alone I give him an edge)
Lewis slightly< Pinkston (I think Lewis is better than Pink but as far as production goes I give the edge to Pink because  he's got a higher ypc average.)
Brown slightly< Mitchell (Same as above.  Reggie is the real deal though)
LJ > Chad (I hate to say it but Chad could only dream about a game like LJ had today.  His blocking has improved too.)

[TexasEagle]

Since it's only been two games I'm not sure I see the point in doing evaluations now, especialy since the games they've played have been polar opposites of each other offensively so it's hard to say this person is doing better than that person might/would have. This is a better topic for week 17.

[Sgt PSN]

Hey, look at meeeeeeeee!  I'm trying to be logical.  Look at meeeeeeee!

Shut up slut!  

[MadMarchHare]

I've been a Pinky hater for a long time.  That being said, Greg had 3 passes thrown deep to him that were broken up;  largely because he was the same height as the CB.  ToothPink, being considerably taller, could've made a better target.

Start McMullen!

[pinoyboy2pt0]

Clarke=>Hicks

Mayberry>Andrews

but I think after 1-2 weeks...then for the rest of the season...Andrews>>Mayberry


On a side note...

Simoneau (the girl) had an AWESOME game!! I slam the lady left and right...but he had a great hit on ST K.O., kicked a farging PAT and even popped Alex Smith.  Games like that from him make me happy.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Mrs. Simoneau did indeed have a little fire in her today. Good to see.

Andrews < Mayberry - I love Big Nasty, you guys know that. However he is not as consistent as Jermane was yet (obviously). But I would take Shawn over him now either way because of the potential. And Jermane is breaking down. Shawn has had some injuries but nothing like Mayberry has. I hope his shoulder is OK.

Patterson > Simon - Mike is making plays and he looks like Corey did in his rookie year. Now that Simon has added a Volkswagen to his beltline, I'll take Mike.

Lewis < Pinkston - Yeah I ripped Todd The Vadge. But until Lewis puts up better numbers than Pink, I say Pink is greater. It won't stay like this forever, but I'm just being honest.

Brown > Mitchell - Reggie gets open. Freddie didn't. Reggie plays STs. Freddie didn't. Reggie doesn't point to his Swatch Watch. Freddie did. And so on...

L.J > Chad - Chad was not the starter last year; Smith was.

Spach < Chad - Lewis will be missed as the #2 TE until Spach gets acclimated in the offense and gains 5's trust.

[SD_Eagle5]

LJ had a fantastic day. Julian Peterson is one of the best cover LBs in the league and couldn't handle him.

Lamar Gordon > Dorsey Levens

[WEST is GOD]

Gordon is better than Levens IMO. When I said that a month or so ago everyone on here got on me for making ridiculous comments. How could I possibly want Gordon over Levens?!

[Susquehanna Birder]

Spach < Chad

For now. I think Spach has the look of an early Chad, and he could very well flourish. I think he'll get Nabby's trust soon enough.