It's the offseason so it's time for mind numbing, hypothetical discussions that make no sense.
This comment by Dio ......
Quote from: Diomedes on January 26, 2007, 05:12:48 PM
I'd trade McNabb for one super bowl.
.... got me thinking. We've all got individual attachments to certain players for one reason or another. Players that we want to see win a SB with the Eagles. Obviously the goal is for the Eagles to win the SB. But would you feel differently about it if your favorite player wasn't on the team when it happened? Are there any players that you
wouldn't trade for a SB? Or do you really not care in the least who is or isn't a part of the team if the Eagles win the big game?
For me, I wouldn't trade Dawkins. He's been a staple on this team for a decade and has been a major factor in the Eagles success over the last 6 years. He is a true Philadelphia Eagle and if given the opportunity to trade him for a sure fire SB win, I would still have to decline. I'd rather take my chances with him on the field and hope that the Eagles win one rather than watch this team hoist one up without him.
Everyone else on the roster is fair game. I'd love to see McNabb lead this team to the promised land but if it's Garcia, Feeley, whoever, then so be it. Same goes for everyone else.
For the right price, any of 'em are tradeable. Even Chris Gocong.
Westbrook and Dawkins, and I love Runyan. Everyone else is on the table.
Remarkably, Dio's list is my list. Exactly. Probably wouldn't trade Andrews either.
Quote from: Diomedes on January 26, 2007, 06:12:21 PM
Westbrook and Dawkins, and I love Runyan. Everyone else is on the table.
Akers isn't protected? I figured he'd be first on your list. Actually, I figured he'd be your list.
Quote from: Diomedes on January 26, 2007, 06:12:21 PM
Westbrook and Dawkins, and I love Runyan. Everyone else is on the table.
:yay
I'm not giving up Baskett either. So don't ask.
McNabb
Dawkins
Westbrook
Andrews
Jackson
Cole
Lito
Reggie Brown
There are no untouchables on the Eagles in my mind. I'd trade McNabb for a proven pro-bowl receiver or linebacker and mutiple draft picks, just no a draft pick.
That list is too long.
You're telling me you wouldn't trade Reggie Brown for 3 1st round picks or Jamaal farging Jackson for 4?
McNabb
Dawkins
Westbrook
(possibly) Andrews
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on January 26, 2007, 06:55:25 PM
McNabb
Dawkins
Westbrook
Andrews
Jackson
Cole
Lito
Reggie Brown
Damn Phreak. You really saying you wouldn't give up any of those guys for a SB?
Quote from: FFatPatt on January 26, 2007, 08:11:39 PM
That list is too long.
You're telling me you wouldn't trade...Jamaal farging Jackson for 4?
Hell farg No!
Well, if I would have read the whole post then I would have had a clue. I'm a dope. And if someone offered me 3 #1's for Reggie, I would do it.
I was talking about who I would not trade in regards to building the team.
LOL - this is a stupid question. Are you kidding here or what?
Ha!
I would trade everyone who ever played for the Eagles, my friends, extended family, and all of you (gladly) for an Eagles Super Bowl win.
yeah i dont get it or i dont understand the question....are people saying there are players on the eagles they wouldnt trade for a superbowl?
as far untouchables just in general theres only one and thats shawn andrews
Quote from: rjs246 on January 26, 2007, 06:30:20 PMProbably wouldn't trade Andrews either.
My bad. Him too.
Andrews. Detmer.
If the question refers to trading someone for a superbowl, then there isn't anyone I would list. farg all of them. The team wins, not a player.
I'm with the trade anyone/everyone camp although losing Reno would break my heart. But hey, it's a (hypothetical irrelevant) business.
As much as I love Dawk, we're talking about a Super Bowl win.
We love you bud, but don't let the door hit you in the ass...
Quote from: rjs246 on January 26, 2007, 11:33:43 PM
If the question refers to trading someone for a superbowl, then there isn't anyone I would list. farg all of them. The team wins, not a player.
.
No doubt
sorry kids, but Daddy has traded you to the evil family next door so the Eagles he can get their Super Bowl.
hmmmmmm. Tough decision.... Yeah, I think I'd do it.
I honestly don't have a true emotional attachment to anyone on the team. I don't care who's there when it happens. I just want the Birds to win. For us. farg them.
Quote from: MadMarchHare on January 28, 2007, 05:22:13 PM
I honestly don't have a true emotional attachment to anyone on the team. I don't care who's there when it happens. I just want the Birds to win. For us. farg them.
The only player I have any kind of emotional attachment to would be Dawkins. For a Super Bowl, I'd send him packing. For a Super Bowl trophy, I'd give my left nut. Heck, take 'em both. I already have two kids (well, almost), and don't want any more anyway. >:D
I'd give up a kidney and part of my liver for a SB.
Quote from: Seabiscuit36 on January 28, 2007, 08:15:43 PM
I'd give up a kidney and part of my liver for a SB.
Most of the guys on this board have already given up a part of their liver. Not for the Eagles, though.
They're not real fans. :D
Reminder: Phreak wouldn't trade Jamaal Jackson for a Super Bowl.
Incorrect. I read the question wrong. :flipoff
By the way thanks FF for getting the Mr Deeds Ficus line stuck in my head lastnight and today. All day long im finishing my basement and like a robot saying Pressstonnn
While you were working on it, you should have put "Mr. Deeds" on your new TV. That would have been a hoot!
I decided I still would trade anyone for a Super Bowl, but the only player being gone that would slightly (very slightly) reduce my enjoyment of the win would be Dawkins. I have reasons to sort of hate everyone else, or at least I just don't care about them as players/people yet.
Quote from: Seabiscuit36 on January 28, 2007, 08:15:43 PM
I'd give up a kidney and part of my liver for a SB.
LOL - we do that every time we tailgate, doode. :-D
Not Sunmo :-D
ha
I wouldn't trade Andy Reid for a Super Bowl
Think of all the good things he's done for us.
well he gave us 2 kids that show us to say NO TO DRUGS and that you shouldnt brandish a gun in broad daylight outside of Philly if you dont wanna get caught
Can we get a custom title for phillywin2k5?
Options:
Thread Bumper
Worm Can Opener
Douche Brain Face
Ok, I was just kidding about the last one. ROFLcopterLOLlerskatesHANDUKEN
so this grasshoper walks into this bar and asks the bartender for a drink...bartender says we don't serve your kind in here....grasshoper says come on! i'm a nice guy!
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:40:06 PM
Can we get a custom title for phillywin2k5?
Options:
Thread Bumper
Worm Can Opener
Douche Brain Face
Ok, I was just kidding about the last one. ROFLcopterLOLlerskatesHANDUKEN
Probably thread bumper, im just tired of going to Philly.com each day and the top story is one of 2 things, Reids kids and the daily murder blog.
There are a lot of available solutions for you:
Kill Reid's kids.
Throw your computer into the Schuylkill.
Get AIDS and die.
Stop complaining and choose your plan of action.
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:46:55 PM
There are a lot of available solutions for you:
Kill Reid's kids.
Throw your computer into the Schuylkill.
Get AIDS and die.
Stop complaining and choose your plan of action.
Hmm...The get AIDS and die is intriguing but it takes so long, just look at Magic Johnson!
I know. He's on my ghoulpool list for this year, and last I heard, he doesn't even have HIV anymore or something.
He does have lots of illegitimate children though, so that's pretty awesome.
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:53:42 PM
I know. He's on my ghoulpool list for this year, and last I heard, he doesn't even have HIV anymore or something.
i need to get in on one of those! For all those years they thought it was HIV when in fact it was a really bad case of crabs.
Crabs are no joke. I had a cousin who died from crabs. Or cancer. I don't remember which.
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:53:42 PM
I know. He's on my ghoulpool list for this year, and last I heard, he doesn't even have HIV anymore or something.
Just heard Tommy Morrison is now AIDs free and licensed to Box again. Wonder what brave soul will be his first opponent.
Quote from: SD_Eagle on February 20, 2007, 05:31:19 PM
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:53:42 PM
I know. He's on my ghoulpool list for this year, and last I heard, he doesn't even have HIV anymore or something.
Just heard Tommy Morrison is now AIDs free and licensed to Box again. Wonder what brave soul will be his first opponent.
I'd throw him in the right with Tyson just to see if the sob is really dumb enough to bite him.
Sadly that would be the best heavyweight fight in years....
Yeah, pretty much.
Quote from: Sgt PSN on February 20, 2007, 07:16:54 PM
Quote from: SD_Eagle on February 20, 2007, 05:31:19 PM
Quote from: FFatPatt on February 20, 2007, 04:53:42 PM
I know. He's on my ghoulpool list for this year, and last I heard, he doesn't even have HIV anymore or something.
Just heard Tommy Morrison is now AIDs free and licensed to Box again. Wonder what brave soul will be his first opponent.
I'd throw him in the right with Tyson just to see if the sob is really dumb enough to bite him.
let Magic Johnson fight him..