Without knowing the extent of McNabb's injury, and it looks bad, I do not want to see Jeff Garcia week after week. He has no arm strength.
Like 2002 - Start AJ.
He knows this offense and he has a good arm. He looked excellent in the preseason game.
This farging SUCKS! :-\
I wouldn't go crazy yet, bro.
Quote from: Eaglez on November 19, 2006, 02:11:19 PM
I wouldn't go crazy yet, bro.
We're Eagles fans. We start out that way.
True, but we really don't know the extent of McNabb's injury. We haven't heard anything yet, and he's been back in the locker room for a pretty long time, but I'm not about to speculate yet.
We'll hear something at half time. If he broke something or tore something I think word would have came out by now.
That was an excellent play by Garcia.
Honestly there are bigger issues, like playcalling. Even with McNabb in the beginning on the game, we were down. I don't care who starts if McNabb is gone for sometime...this season is offically OVER if McNabb is out for nxt weeks game or longer...say your prayers.
So you say that the playcalling, because they weren't running it in the 1st quarter, was bad? The game was not over because they were down even with McNabb in there.
Regardless - start Feeley.
I'm going to take the stupid positive approach and say that if McNabb is out for long, we'll run the ball more, which actually might give us a shot at winning some games. If we can somehow stumble to 9-7, we might make the playoffs.
[/hopeless hope]
The playcalling has been zesty all year Phreak...thats the point, regardless of run or pass. Who gives a farg who's passing...the season is over if McNabb is injured.
Quote from: mussa on November 19, 2006, 02:51:21 PM
The playcalling has been zesty all year Phreak...thats the point, regardless of run or pass. Who gives a farg who's passing...the season is over if McNabb is injured.
No shtein, but it was the first quarter and you were like "we were down" like the game was over because the play calling and being down 7-0 or 7-3 in the 1st.
Fine...overstatement...negladelphi statement...fair enough, now admit the playcalling is horrendous.
I'll admit it. Now will Reid & Co.?
Put AJ in. Now.
Put in Bartrum!
I bet the NFL execs are pissed they moved that Colts game now. :-D
Andy said he is going to look at the film to see who starts.
Here's some help, Big Red; Start Feeley.
Garcia looked like death warmed over. The dude's arm is weaker than a 6yr old's.
AJ was taking warm up snaps in the 4th but never went in.
But you know what? In 2002 they had a guy who could move the sticks (Duce) and a defense who rose to the challenge. This team has NO BALLS and NO HEART and cannot replicate what that 2002 team did.
I remember Duce's "the general has been shot" quote and then went out and played like hell.
This team is going to go in the tank.
8-12 months; I mean, this is career-threatening. Not insomuch that he will never come back, but just whether McNabb will ever be the same after this injury.
It was such a freak injury as well. I mean, he was barely touched. Only in Philadelphia.
The season is over. Jeff will do nothing for this team. Start AJ please.
farg farg farg farg farg
Start whoever. Yay whoever.
Quote from: Diomedes on November 19, 2006, 04:59:26 PM
Start whoever. Yay whoever.
Word.
It doesn't matter who the hell is starting at QB. This team is done... and I'm not just talking about not making the playoffs done. I'm talking 5-11 done.
I bet Lispy McHasnoarm starts against the Colts after getting a week of practice and then we'll see AJ after the Colts put a 42-7 whuppin on that ass next week.
I want Garcia to start. That way, everyone who thought it was a good signing will have to see him look like a fool 45 times a game for the rest of the season. I hope those people remember what they thought about him when he was signed every time he drops back.
Quote from: Munson on November 19, 2006, 02:42:39 PM
I'm going to take the stupid positive approach and say that if McNabb is out for long, we'll run the ball more, which actually might give us a shot at winning some games. If we can somehow stumble to 9-7, we might make the playoffs.
[/hopeless hope]
i've never felt embarassed for someone after a message board post, until now
Quote from: SunMo on November 19, 2006, 07:32:29 PM
Quote from: Munson on November 19, 2006, 02:42:39 PM
I'm going to take the stupid positive approach and say that if McNabb is out for long, we'll run the ball more, which actually might give us a shot at winning some games. If we can somehow stumble to 9-7, we might make the playoffs.
[/hopeless hope]
i've never felt embarassed for someone after a message board post, until now
I've never felt so embarrased for someone who can't pick up on sarcasm, even when I make it obvious at the end of the post with the hopeless hope comment.
Carry on.
you should be embrassed that ,even if you were being sarcastic (which you weren't), that somebody would think you are serious. it goes to show how douchey your football views are. but as i said, you weren't being sarcastic.
:-D Okay dude, keep telling me what I meant with my post. I even threw in "stupid positive approach" in addition to the last part to make it easy for the dolts like you. Seems like you're the only one who felt I was being serious about it.
you were serious, stop trying to pretend you weren't.
yeah, you said "i'm going to take the stupid positive approach" meaning what? YOU are taking the stupid positive approach.
but yes, i'm the dolt. DOLT! killer insult maaaaaaan.
:-D
You're just too much. I love how you're trying to tell me how I meant my post. Oh boy...you've given me a better laugh then both a racist taterskins fan, AND a terrible game by the Eagles today. You should be proud.
Quote from: Munson on November 19, 2006, 07:49:54 PM
:-D
You're just too much. I love how you're trying to tell me how I meant my post. Oh boy...you've given me a better laugh then both a racist taterskins fan, AND a terrible game by the Eagles today. You should be proud.
keep posting smilies, they really give the effect that you're laughing, while we all know that you probably have the hot feeling in your face because your pissed off about being revealed as a total douche on a message board.
and as for your other post, there really is no interpretation required, so stop trying to act like i missed it, or that i'm trying to "tell you what you meant". we know what you meant, it's plain as day. by now you probably regret posting it, and are trying to get out of it with your smiley assault and by presenting the theory that i don't "get" what you were trying to say. sorry pal, it's not working. you're just a douche who has the brainpower that makes a down syndrome patient sound like a super genius.
probably your best bet would be to turn off the computer, and go sit in a dark corner somewhere to calm down, I would say you should count to 10, but that would probably just anger you more when you couldn't remember what came after 4. so just relax, and maybe give some serious consideration to what myself and many have suggested for you, suicide. it really would be best for your friends, family, and the human race in general. k? thanks.
oh, and i'll give you something you can understand perfectly:
:o >:D :boom :evil :bash :fire :nyuk :chair
Oooo...you said I make down syndrome people look smart. Buuuurn. Nice use of "douche" too...you're really comin up with some fresh material.
Dude, I made it obvious I was being sarcastic, and if you want to be pissy about itbecause you think I'm some homertastic poster, that's fine. I knew the Eagles weren't going to run the ball anymore regaurdless, let alone when Jeff Garcia's first 4 plays were pass plays. And the title of this thread alone lets everyone with eyes who can see it know that the Eagles season is over. I decided to be sarcastic and take the ES approach to the rest of our doomed season. I know you just want to try and make fun of someone and puff up your cyber ego some more....and for that, it has humored me greatly and I've gotten a good :-D out of it.
:win :bow :crazy :chair :fire :bash :flipoff :afro :afro :afro :afro
OK, here we go with the gradeschool idiot 'no it didn't, yes you did', bullshtein.
If you two iceholes wanna' act like two little girls in the sandpile who took the others shovel, do it somewere else.
This season just got canceled and no one wants to read your ignorant panties in a bunch bullcrap.
Start Feeley, please. I didn't want that noodle armed has been in the first place. It was a waste of money. Reid would have done better to sign Testaverde, at least he can throw it over 30 yards.
I would have started this thread if it wasn't already here.
As I said after the pre-season, Garcia is brutal and should have retired by now.
Quote from: General_Failure on November 19, 2006, 05:10:30 PM
I want Garcia to start. That way, everyone who thought it was a good signing will have to see him look like a fool 45 times a game for the rest of the season. I hope those people remember what they thought about him when he was signed every time he drops back.
It's all relative. Mike Mc was just brutal. I hope they go with Feely. If nothing else, determine if he is in the long term future.
He's not.
If nothing else, determine if he is in the long term future.
he has no future he sucks
they need to draft a young qb this year to groom if not as the starter one day then at least as a good back up...someone like a schaub
They'll draft a QB next year for sure. They were lookin at 'em the past two years and Schaub was one of the guys who they loved but ATL got him higher than they thought he'd go. They also were in love with Gradkowski and Kellen Clemens this past year.
AJ has a 2yr deal. He'll be the #2 next year with the rookie holding the clipboard.
A start Feeley thread? The sky has officially fallen... :boom
Quote from: Phanatic on November 20, 2006, 12:37:15 PM
A start Feeley thread? The sky has officially fallen... :boom
At least it wasn't created until McNabb went down with injury. So we have that going for us.
which is horrible
Quote from: SunMo on November 20, 2006, 12:48:05 PM
which is horrible
What's horrible is I'm actually still caring about whether they start Garcia, Feeley, or Y.A. Tittle.
which is horrible
wanna hear something really horrible...on the radio they are saying feely has to start because they are gonna need a qb to play the first half of next year and they wanna see if hes the man
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 20, 2006, 01:23:21 PM
which is horrible
wanna here something really horrible...on the radio they are saying feely has to start because they are gonna need a qb to play the first half of next year and they wanna see if hes the man
:puke
Mort says that Feeley and Garcia will get equal reps in practice and whoever plays best will start.
And then Feeley can lead us to a Super Bowl!
and once he names a starter, the other will be relegated to filling up water bottles
I'm already getting excited for this game! I hope Koy comes in and beats them all for the starting spot.
The McNabb injury is a blessing in disguise. Neckbeard is the only QB in the land capable of leading this team to Super Bowl glory.
Inky says Garcia is likely to start this game. :boo
That signifies that Andy Reid is holding onto the false hope that this team has a chance to win an of their remaining games, which I will believe when I see.
Then the big question is: How quick of a hook will Reid have on Garcia?
The first time he short hops a 15yd in route. Which will be about 6 snaps into the game. He's got happy feet, no arm strength and is like a damn crackhead in the pocket because he's so jittery.
I don't feel like searching the forum but SI.com mentions that the Eagles and Jake Plummer could be a match in the near future.
^^^^ Ban for avatar......
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 21, 2006, 11:25:45 AM
The first time he short hops a 15yd in route. Which will be about 6 snaps into the game. He's got happy feet, no arm strength and is like a damn crackhead in the pocket because he's so jittery.
Hopefully that will be before he's asked to throw deep.
A 15yd in route IS deep for Garcia.
Maybe the halfback option is the way to go. Can Westbrook throw deep?
Quote from: Susquehanna Birder on November 21, 2006, 01:15:01 PM
Maybe the halfback option is the way to go. Can Westbrook throw deep?
Kevin Johnson used to be a QB. I'm just sayin'.
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 21, 2006, 11:12:15 AM
Inky says Garcia is likely to start this game. :boo
Jesus farging Christ! I'm not gonna' be able to keep watching if Reid keeps playing that guy. What the farg is he expecting from him?? He had 22 incompletions Sunday against the friggen' Titans!!
START FEELEY GODDAMMITT!!
Feeley was on Preston and Steve about an hour ago and said he was on his way to the NC complex and would find out who the starter is first thing this morning. He didn't sound too optimistic.
ridiculous if garcia starts and it will only be the case because hes morningwhegs guy
well they did sign Garcia to be the #2 QB... whats the big deal?
he sucks? hard?
i dont think feely is great by any means but he gives them a much better chance to win and garcia wouldnt even be on the team had feely been available at the time
then again reid played joselio hanson over rod hood so i dont think he is really that concerned with putting the best possible team on the field
There is nothing to be gained by starting Garcia. He's Blake, McMahon, etc. Let him hold that backup spot for in game replacement of an injured QB.
Put Feeley out there and see what he can do. He might even make the team for next year if he wins a few. Garcia is worthless at this point..no upside at all, certainly doens't offer a better chance of winning now.
Quote from: MURP on November 22, 2006, 09:25:48 AM
well they did sign Garcia to be the #2 QB... whats the big deal?
If Feeley were available at the time I doubt Garcia would have been signed to be the #2.
also, remember they were comapring the new #2 to Mike McMahon. at that point, Dennis Byrd lookied like a great option at #2 QB.
gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:17:30 AM
gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting
What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.
Quote from: SD_Eagle on November 22, 2006, 10:19:14 AM
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:17:30 AM
gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting
What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.
The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice. If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.
Quote from: Philly_Crew on November 22, 2006, 10:39:45 AM
The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice. If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.
but this is the playoff push! they don't have one game to waste!
Who cares who starts? McNabb went down so did the season.
It wouldn't of mattered anyway. We have Stay-Puft running the team into the ground.
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
I can accept the fact that the seasons over, what I can't accept
Quote from: Philly_Crew on November 22, 2006, 10:39:45 AM
Quote from: SD_Eagle on November 22, 2006, 10:19:14 AM
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:17:30 AM
gargano just confirmed garcia will be starting
What a load of shtein. I hope Andy chokes on his Thanksgiving dinner.
The more I think about it, I don't mind one start by Garcia to see what he can do with a full week of practice. If he looks as jumpy and weak-armed as last week, then start Feeley.
Unless they pumped him full of Steroids this past week none of that is going to change. He's still gonna run out of the pocket the first chance he gets, and his arm is done. It's been done. The fact that he lead the Niners to the playoffs 5 years ago shouldn't factor into what he can do now.
At least with AJ you have a younger guy with a strong arm who can build a future to be a solid #2 for 5-10 years.
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
yes.
aj had a couple decent games 4 years ago...garcia is much more proven if they're thinking win now to make the playoffs.
personally, i didn't think they'd make the playoffs with mcnabb, let alone garcia, but i guess they have to try.
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
We don't know who gives us the best chance and neither did Andy last week because apparently no one was getting any snaps with the first team.
The only thing that would make this interesting is if they put the rookies in like they did last year. Then at least we'd have some more incentive to see what we have next year.
garcia hasn't been an effective quarterback in 3 years
Quote from: SD_Eagle on November 22, 2006, 10:50:43 AMThe fact that he lead the Niners to the playoffs 5 years ago shouldn't factor into what he can do now.
We'll see...but I tend to agree with you. He knows the offense, but his arm is probably best suited for holding a clipboard.
aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.
Quote from: hunt on November 22, 2006, 10:55:35 AM
aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.
4-1...seemed pretty effective then
aj had a couple decent games 4 years ago...garcia is much more proven if they're thinking win now to make the playoffs.
that only makes sense if right now it was four years ago
aj has been in this exact same situation before and DID IT
just because youre older doesnt mean youre better...age is only an advantage when youre talking about a rookie or a guy whos never started in the nfl...and its a disadvantage when youre 36 and cant play anymore
the only thing that garcia has 'proven' is that hes finished
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 10:54:28 AM
garcia hasn't been an effective quarterback in 3 years
considering the teams he was with you cant be that surprised.
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 10:57:10 AM
Quote from: hunt on November 22, 2006, 10:55:35 AM
aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.
4-1...seemed pretty effective then
3-8...seemed pretty ineffective then
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.
i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.
I hope Freeney sacks Garcia and he dislocates his elbow. De Ja Vu is a bitch.
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 10:57:10 AM
Quote from: hunt on November 22, 2006, 10:55:35 AM
aj hasn't be an effective qb ever.
4-1...seemed pretty effective then
you know better than that...the team won but aj did nothing. go back & look up his stats.
the D carried that team.
yeah, he had a team full of offensive weapons in Miami, didn't he?
Quote from: Wingspan on November 22, 2006, 11:00:29 AM
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.
i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.
Feeley thrived in this system, I don't care what he did with the Dolphins or Chargers. Garcia sucks, he's sucked since he left the Niners.
This argument is idiotic. They both suck. One is younger and should be given a chance because this season is OVER.
its no doubt that we're arguing between who's the better lay...the fat chick or the handicapped chick. but in that discussion, it's somewhat obvious that Feely is the better option.
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 11:01:03 AM
yeah, he had a team full of offensive weapons in Miami, didn't he?
Randy McMichael, Chris Chambers, and Marty Booker were better than Todd Pinkston, James Thrash and Chad Lewis
no offensive line and no running back
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 11:03:32 AM
its no doubt that we're arguing between who's the better lay...the fat chick or the handicapped chick. but in that discussion, it's somewhat obvious that Feely is the better option.
That depends, is the handicapped chick fat too?
no, she's mid-sized
feely does suck...but hes better than garcia and thats all that matters right now....garcia is so easy to defend since he literally cant throw a ball outside of the flat
whether feely will be able to throw it down field is a question no one can answer but at least he is physically able to do so
you cant start a qb in a passing offense when he can only make one or two throws in the nfl
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 11:05:10 AM
you cant throw a qb into a passing offense when he can only make one or two throws in the nfl
don't forget the fact that he has no pocket presence as well
Quote from: SD_Eagle on November 22, 2006, 11:02:17 AM
Quote from: Wingspan on November 22, 2006, 11:00:29 AM
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.
i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.
Feeley thrived in this system, I don't care what he did with the Dolphins or Chargers. Garcia sucks, he's sucked since he left the Niners.
thrived?
http://www.nfl.com/players/playerpage/235056/gamelogs/2002
Dude, accounting for 5 TDs while turning the ball over 6 times is the DEFINITION of thriving.
say what you want about Feely, but how can you even begin to argue for Jeff Garcia...he's done as done
^^^^^
thats it
as usual hunt is missing the point
its not whether feely is good or not he clearly isnt...but at least he has tools to succeed in this league...garcia is incapable of playing anymore perios...has anyone watched him the last two years
this is a case of a guy who isnt very good and probably wont make any plays to win but at least has the possibility of doing so vs a guy who cant play the game anymore
why is that so hard to understand
Quote from: SD_Eagle on November 22, 2006, 11:02:17 AM
Quote from: Wingspan on November 22, 2006, 11:00:29 AM
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 22, 2006, 10:43:44 AM
i understand the it doesnt matter crowd and im not preaching a playoff berth or anything but dont you think its fundamentally wrong to start a lesser player when youre one game out of the division just because your OC is freinds with him and told him to come to philly
i mean no one truly believes that reid thinks garcia gives them a better chance to win do they?
everyone seems to forget that feeley actually sucks. he was beaten out by 2 guys who never played an NFL game before this past summer.
i think garcia gives them a better chance to win. it's not leaps and bounds. but a better chance nonetheless.
Feeley thrived in this system, I don't care what he did with the Dolphins or Chargers. Garcia sucks, he's sucked since he left the Niners.
no, he really did not.
Feeley's starts in 2002 went like this
W 10-3 Vs the Rams
Bobby Taylor returned an INT for a TD in the first quarter. the rams sucked that year by the way
W 27-20 vs seattle
this was a solid Feeley effort here
W 27-20 vs washington
this was a solid Feeley effort here
W 27-3 vs dallas
feeley actually sucked in this game, the defense and the running attack did this one.
L 7-10 in OT
feeley sucked here two, and this was where they backed into HFA
Feely had 2 decent games 4 years ago....
PERIOS!
lol @ u
garcia used to be good...feeley was never good, even when he was handed a starting job in miami.
saying feeley is cleary better right now is pure bunk...what has he done to show he's better?
he's shown he's not Jeff Garcia...who doesn't belong in the league
garcia used to be good...feeley was never good
GET MARINO!
I'll detract from saying he 'thrived' because stat wise I can't back it up, but he was 4-1 as the starter, he's not 47 years old and won't scramble out of the pocket at the first sign of pressure. Garcia sucks. He was an awful F/A signing. If Feeley had been available he's not on the team.
I don't see how Feeley offers a worse chance of winning the game this weekend.
I don't see how the investment made in starting Garcia offers a better chance of positive long term returns.
I do however understand the comment "who cares which one starts." That's true, so I'm not gonna get worked up about farging Garcia.
Whatever, Andy.
Quote from: Diomedes on November 22, 2006, 11:45:05 AM
I do however understand the comment "who cares which one starts." That's true, so I'm not gonna get worked up about farging Garcia.
Whatever, Andy.
word to that.
yeah, sounds about right
Quote from: SunMo on November 22, 2006, 11:24:14 AM
he's shown he's not Jeff Garcia...who doesn't belong in the league
don't worry...aj will get his chance in a couple weeks when the eagles are out of contention.
agreed
im still salty over the hood thing and i just dont want garcia starting cause hes martys boy and because he got him here he feels as tho he has to start
if andy truly believes garcia is the better choice then hes an idiot but i can live with that....but if its some shady shtein like the hood thing and the best guy is not starting for reasons other than football then farg that
i'd rather argue about which one of them is banging the hotter chick. it's pretty close.
an excellent idea.
which one of you dorks wants to put up some pics?
Carmela Decesare (http://www.sescoops.com/galleries/carmella/164c_Carmella_Decesare_1.jpg) (Garcia's chick)
There are plenty more pics of her that are less safe for work.
Heather Mitts (http://msn.foxsports.com/id/5424368_7_4.jpg) (Feeley's chick)
Plenty more available, but no boobage.
Quote from: phattymatty on November 22, 2006, 12:01:28 PM
i'd rather argue about which one of them is banging the hotter chick. it's pretty close.
I don't think its remotely close. Garcia's beard is WAY hotter than Feeley's beard.
(Come on, you don't actually think that either of them are straight, do you? High pitched, lispy voices. Over the top public attractive girlfriends. Noodle arms...)
Poor choice by Andy.
I hope he has a quick hook. Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 22, 2006, 02:28:25 PM
Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.
What was the year we had guys like Brad Goebel, Dave Archer, and Jeff Kemp taking snaps?
Let's totally go back to that!
Quote from: FFatPatt on November 22, 2006, 03:12:13 PM
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 22, 2006, 02:28:25 PM
Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.
What was the year we had guys like Brad Goebel, Dave Archer, and Jeff Kemp taking snaps?
Let's totally go back to that!
1991, I believe.
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 22, 2006, 02:28:25 PM
Poor choice by Andy.
I hope he has a quick hook. Or that Jeff breaks an ankle.
I just do
not understand what that hardheaded bitch is thinking. My 15 year old High Schooler can tell Garcia is done. Is Reid just giving up on the whole season?? 22 incompletions weren't enough for him?? You supposedly have a offense geared to the big deep play. Wouldn't you want a qb who can throw the ball farther than 20 yds. downfield?? I'm baffled by this decision.
Remember when we signed Feeley, and I was campaining for him to move up on the depth chart ahead of Garcia?? It was said that discussion of who would be the second and third string qb was ridiculous and stupid. Now, here is a whole thread dedicated to the subject.
:flipoff all you people who ridiculed me, you know who you are.
Great, just great. (http://www.phillyburbs.com/pb-dyn/news/99-11232006-746176.html)
Quote"He's the quarterback and there's not a short leash," Reid said. "I brought Jeff in here for this situation, if something were to happen to Donovan. I have a lot of trust in Jeff. I have a lot of trust in A.J., too, but I brought Jeff in for this reason. He's a pretty good quarterback."
The poll on the Phillyblurb site has Feeley beating Garcia 77.2% to 22.8%.
"He's the quarterback and there's not a short leash," Reid said. "I brought Jeff in here for this situation, if something were to happen to Donovan. I have a lot of trust in Jeff. I have a lot of trust in A.J., too, but I brought Jeff in for this reason. He's a pretty good quarterback."
just as i thought...the best guy is not starting...instead garcia is only starting because andy told him he was the #2 when he signed him....stupid ass you play people who give you the best chance to win not who you told would play in april
Isn't it obvious Andy is TRYING to lose so he can get the best possible linemen available in the draft? I thought that was obvious.
LOL @ Spuds' comment (http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/news/newsDetail.jsp?id=60100) on Garthia:
Quote
Garcia has a fire, an emotional intensity, that he carries with him. These last couple of seasons have dampened his spirit and his performance, certainly. We remember Garcia as the tough little quarterback in San Francisco, the guy with, as Garcia put it, "grit" in his game. He could ruin a defense with a scramble here and there and consistency in picking apart a defense in a variety of ways. He was a tough bugger, for sure.
How hard was he when he wrote that?
That's the most bonertastic quote I've seen from Spadaro in a while. Spadaro really reaches new heights in how much he tries to sell this team as a success when obviously they aren't.
Granted, that's his job. I wouldn't expect him to rip the Eagles on the Eagles official homepage. Who is going to trash their own product?
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 19, 2006, 02:08:57 PM
Without knowing the extent of McNabb\'s injury, and it looks bad, I do not want to see Jeff Garcia week after week. He has no arm strength.
Like 2002 - Start AJ.
He knows this offense and he has a good arm. He looked excellent in the preseason game.
This farging SUCKS! :-\\
Good call Phreak! Way to show that football knowledge.
I was wrong as wrong can be. And I have no problem admitting it.
I didn't think this defense could rise to the occasion either.
Shall we go pull up some of your dumbass statements? How about Dawk being done? Move him to WIL!
Nice football knowledge, jitbag.
Quote from: ice grillin you on November 23, 2006, 05:56:43 PM
"He's the quarterback and there's not a short leash," Reid said. "I brought Jeff in here for this situation, if something were to happen to Donovan. I have a lot of trust in Jeff. I have a lot of trust in A.J., too, but I brought Jeff in for this reason. He's a pretty good quarterback."
just as i thought...the best guy is not starting...instead garcia is only starting because andy told him he was the #2 when he signed him....stupid ass you play people who give you the best chance to win not who you told would play in april
:-D
How about that Spadaro comment now, Sus? :)
Maybe all this crow that is being dissed out will lead to a more reasoned discussion on this board... probably not.
In defense if Phreak he made that comment right after McNabb went down. Everyone else had time to take a step back and contemplate their posts after that. You should be pulling out posts of people who had some time to actually think and evaluate their posts. I'm sure there probably isn't a shortage of those.
I was in favor of starting AJ whether I posted it or not on this board. I didn't have confidence in Garcia, the defense, or the special teams. Garcia and the defense has surprised me, along with the coaching staff actually calling farging run plays consistently. The O-line has been great all year long and Westbrook is the best player on the team, and needs more carries. :o Which is what 80% of these posters on this board have said all year long.
Either way, I still have confidence in AJ if given the chance.
I still think Garcia sucks. And he does.
He might, but Feeley couldn't run this offense any better. He has a better arm and would open things up deep, but I can't say anything bad about what Garcia has done so far. I'll eat my crow and enjoy it.
With the way the run game is, and the way the Eagles sustain drives, the Eagles really don't need to open things up 'deep'. Also, Garcia has shown that he can get the ball deep a few times a game, and demonstrated that against the Giants. Garcia can get it 'deep enough' to stretch a defense, but he's not going to throw it 60 yards in the air like McNabb or other strong-armed NFL QB's, which, at this point, is fine.
I'd rather have a consistent run game and passes ranging from 5-25 yards rather than the occasional bomb that might get 40 yards but then the drive stalls because we can't pick up short yardage consistently.
Quote from: Eaglez on December 26, 2006, 09:10:54 AM
I'd rather have a consistent run game and passes ranging from 5-25 yards rather than the occasional bomb that might get 40 yards
Nevermind the fact that this offense could have had both the whole damned season.
Quote from: General_Failure on December 26, 2006, 10:15:00 AM
Nevermind the fact that this offense could have had both the whole damned season.
yes
Nevermind the fact that this offense could have had both the whole damned season the whole damned decade and won a superbowl or two
Quote from: General_Failure on December 26, 2006, 10:15:00 AM
Quote from: Eaglez on December 26, 2006, 09:10:54 AM
I'd rather have a consistent run game and passes ranging from 5-25 yards rather than the occasional bomb that might get 40 yards
Nevermind the fact that this offense could have had both the whole damned season.
True.
i still stand by Timmy Chang!
This season has proven to me how insane this game is. It's humbling.
Well... a little humbling. Not really.
Looks like AJ will have plenty of time to spend his nights concentrating on football (http://www.ussoccer.com/articles/viewArticle.jsp_281935.html)
I saw her person. farging hot as hell.
Huh, reading this thread again makes me see that all the people here who think they know football and want to bust your balls for not agreeing with them need to sit down and shut up, me included.
Quote from: Munson on November 19, 2006, 02:42:39 PM
I'm going to take the stupid positive approach and say that if McNabb is out for long, we'll run the ball more, which actually might give us a shot at winning some games.
.....amazing......
Quote from: Munson on November 19, 2006, 02:42:39 PM
I'm going to take the stupid positive approach and say that if McNabb is out for long, we'll run the ball more, which actually might give us a shot at winning some games. If we can somehow stumble to 9-7, we might make the playoffs.
[/hopeless hope]
If you're going to quote him and site him as some sort of seer, you should at least use his whole quote. Even he knew he was being an idiot.
What's worse is he turned out being absolutely correct.
He was also right about Westbrook not being injury proned. Just ask him.
Quote from: FastFreddie on May 17, 2007, 07:49:42 PM
What's worse is he turned out being absolutely correct.
Blind. Squirrel. Nut.
Quote from: shorebird on May 17, 2007, 06:07:56 PM
Huh, reading this thread again makes me see that all the people here who think they know football and want to bust your balls for not agreeing with them need to sit down and shut up, me included.
i wouldn't be so hard on yourself or the other idiots. no one could of predicted how well the team played after mcnabb went down. it was a pleasant surprise even though it ended the way it did :-\
What's funny is after they made the playoffs, I made a small attempt to go find that quote, and couldn't. Or maybe I did and just forgot. But either way, my hopeless hope somehow came true. Reid actually ran the damn ball, and they somehow won games.
Oh, and Westbrook still can't carry the load or break 1,000 yards rushing. AIDS.
We all know about you carrying Westbrook's load and whatnot.
(http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/uploads/photos/perm/main/FLBPNPBEAOEN/PE0N6250.JPG)
Quote from: Munson on May 18, 2007, 03:09:42 AM
What's funny is after they made the playoffs, I made a small attempt to go find that quote, and couldn't. Or maybe I did and just forgot.
You were probably too drunk from all that sex you were having.
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on November 19, 2006, 02:08:57 PM
Without knowing the extent of McNabb's injury, and it looks bad, I do not want to see Jeff Garcia week after week. He has no arm strength.
Like 2002 - Start AJ.
He knows this offense and he has a good arm. He looked excellent in the preseason game.
This farging SUCKS! :-\
NICE CALL ON THAT ONE. GENIUS. So much for you having any football knowledge whatsoever. Did you think Garcia knew the offense by then???? Funny stuff from a clueless puffed up fan.
Nice try coming at me for a post immediately after McNabb's knee blew out. No one had seen Garcia since camp & PS when he had no arm strength. Even some of your precious reporters said the same thing as I did.
Now...get back to your fight. You must be working hard.
What's worse...a guy who has 20K posts in five years on this board or some shrimp dick bitch who talks about nothing other than the Eagles ticket office and registers multiple accounts in order to do so?
And then thinks he was banned on order by the Eagles on the official site.
Put yer tinfoil hat on, dooshbag.
Wait, was the point of digging up a 6 month old post? It's not like you've been making fun of this white trash hick for a few years like some of us.
You're the only one allowed to do that, sweetheart.
Git 'er dun!
Quote from: MDS on May 28, 2007, 02:20:23 PM
Wait, was the point of digging up a 6 month old post? It's not like you've been making fun of this white trash hick for a few years like some of us.
Alright its your turn to be Junior Detective. Try to pay attention. Look at the post right above mine. Do you see the date? So the question to you is, who dug up the 6 month old post.
NEXT!!!
Quote from: PhillyPhreak54 on May 28, 2007, 01:43:01 PM
Nice try coming at me for a post immediately after McNabb's knee blew out. No one had seen Garcia since camp & PS when he had no arm strength. Even some of your precious reporters said the same thing as I did.
Now...get back to your fight. You must be working hard.
What's worse...a guy who has 20K posts in five years on this board or some shrimp dick bitch who talks about nothing other than the Eagles ticket office and registers multiple accounts in order to do so?
And then thinks he was banned on order by the Eagles on the official site.
Put yer tinfoil hat on, dooshbag.
Dickless, I was giving you props. You do actually try to think about football things instead of just attacking people. Even if you were way off base, you actually tried to make a rational, well thought out statement on something.
It was totally worthless, and misguided but you tried. You are actually proud of the 20K posts aren't you? Sorry, I didn't mean to offend you. What an accomplishment. So you are a 20K shrimp dick something something, I only gloss over the names, since I haven't been in gradeschool for a really long time.
Good boy. Keep up with the names, it makes you sound really impressive to the girls in gym.
Go away.