ConcreteBoard

Anyone care to post your midseason grades? I'm typing mine up now.

Offense
Defense
Special teams
Coaching
Specific players

F

F-

G-

Incomplete

Offense - C (sometimes plays A game sometimes plays F game, so it balances out)
Defense - C (sometimes plays A game sometimes plays F game, so it balances out)
Special teams - C- (newb squad, Akers out) should only get better
Coaching - C (sometimes coaches A game sometimes F game, so it balances out) I'm including cordinators too.  Seems like it starts out F then goes to A then back to C during the course of the game.
Specific players - that would take me too long

I think we you look at it overall, we're about a 75%, a 4-4 team...which is what we are.  Too inconsistent.

F

They should be the #1 seed in a weak NFC again....

Offense:

Overall offense: D+
The offense has been disappointing so far to say the least. Completely out of rythm, slow starts, bad playcalling, bad clock management, mistakes, the whole deal. A D+ might be generous at this point.

Offensive line: C
They have some good games and some bad. I'm too lazy for details anymore so here are the grades.

QB: C
RBs: D-
TEs: B
WRs: B

Defense overall: F
Defensive line: F
Secondary: F
Linebackers: F

Special teams: D

Coaching: F

O for Sucko!

Please see me after class! >:(

Does not play well with others. :(

Offense D
Defense D-
Special teams D
Coaching F

Specific players
Offense:
McNabb C-
The WR Who shall not be named:  D (play A-, team F)
Akers INC
Westbrook:  D
LJ Smith:  B-
The WRs:  C-
OL:  D

Trotter B
Kearse F
Brown A-
Shepard F
Lewis D
Dawkins B-
The Rest of the Defense FFF


Coaching:
Reid F (worst job of his tenure, IMO)
Johnson D- (ditto)
Childress/Morningwheg F (too many offensive implosions)
Harbaugh:  F

I agree with Phreak in that this season is not over, and mistakes can still be remedied.  However, I am greatly disappointed in the performance of this team this season, from top to bottom.  I don't know if there is a player (apart from rookies like Reggie Brown) that is playing up to their true level, and the team as a whole is far from what I expected to see.

To keep it in educational parlayance, this team is the student failing honors classes.  Obviously the talent is there, but the production just is not.

This season =  :boom

Overall the team is just inconsistant.  Their record reflects a team that suprisingly has too many problems and I'd have to say it starts at the top with Andy Reid.     Plus this years draft class really has not contributed at all.

Grade D

Quote from: 4and26 on November 07, 2005, 09:35:20 AM
Plus this years draft class really has not contributed at all.

kinda a bad time to say that huh?

Offense
C-

Defense
D-
Other than an improved run defense, every other aspect of the defense has blown.

Special teams
C-
Only not an F for the blocked FG

Coaching
offense coaching D+/C- while the run being non-existant, the passing game with TO, Reggie Brown, LJ Smith has been a plus.
defensive coaching F

Offense - D
Defense - C
Special teams - D
Coaching - F

Specific players -  I'll just call out the more or less positive performances, leaving all the rest aside, for obvious reasons.  :(

Offense
Reggie Brown B+ (14 catches for 202yards/14.4ypc, 56yd long,  1TD,  8 first downs)
McMullen B (5catches 120yards/24ypc 38yd long, 4 first downs)

• Given that the former is a rookie and the latter a bum from whom we didn't expect any contribution at all, I have to be pleased with these two WRs.  There's promise here.
  
  Defense:
  Sheldon A
  Patterson B+
  Trotter B- (Dumbass might have rated higher if he didn't go ignorant before the Atlanta game; He should have known better than that, period.)
  
  Special Teams
  Bartrum A

F