Poll
Question:
Should Donovan play againts the 49ers this week?
Option 1: Yes
votes: 13
Option 2: Yes, but only the first half
votes: 3
Option 3: No
votes: 5
I personally think he should sit out... Not to help my Niners, but because a QB out for a game and at 100% the next is better than a QB at 80% for weeks
Apparently you haven't seen Koy play recently. That MNF game was an abberation.
Anyway, McNabb would play regardless, he played for weeks two years ago with a banged up thumb when he probably would have done better sitting for a game or two. He'll play.
If McNabb sat out then I think McMahon would get the start.
Regardless, 80% McNabb is still better than 100% McMahon or Neckbeard. Now if we still had AJ on the other hand....... :P
McMahon would start, not Koy.
Koy would start, suck, and McMahon could come in.
Quote from: MDS on September 15, 2005, 10:47:32 PM
Koy would start, suck, and McMahon could come in.
No. McMahon would start and Koy would be the #2, so he could hold for kicks.
We're getting Blake so he can start this week.
Right. Blake starts, and Koy is the #2 so he can hold for kicks.
Kevin Johnson will be the emergency QB.
Now that we've sorted through all that I feel I can cast my vote.
Owens will start at QB and throw to himself so he can get ALL the credit. >:D
Quote from: General_Failure on September 15, 2005, 11:00:32 PM
Kevin Johnson will be the emergency QB.
What happened to Brian Mitchell?
I heard that we're trading for Urlacher too?
Just until McNabb is healthy, that is....then we'll cut him.
Again I say... if McNabb is not 100%, he plays like 50% or worse. And don't give me that crap about the broken ankle against the Cruds, because the offensive line gave him a ton of time and he was able to be comfortable in the pocket and pick apart the crappy secondary. The 49ers are not a great team, but they will bring pressure. If McNabb is going to ignore opportunities to get first downs with his legs and throw behind and to the feet of receivers, then I do not want him in the game at all. Let him get healthy.
Yes.
I still voted he would only play the first half...figure the game will be over by halftime. It will look like the last preseason game by the fourth quarter. ;D