2013 Grade It

[PhillyPhreak54]

J's gonna get his ass beat if he says "geaux"

hahaha... legit.

hahaha nice

My guy that I work with out of the parent company office is an LSU grad and he's all fired up

[Don Ho]

Sal Pal got Mikey Miss all on board the Tevon Austin thing last week.  Sal wanted it so bad he almost sounded as sickening as Rick Reilly.

[Diomedes]

In new head coach Chip Kelly's offense, you must have...
In this new Chip Kelly offense, there is a demand for...
Chip Kelly's offense requires...

No one knows what kind of system Kelly is going to run, so all of these evaluations are based on bullshtein.  These guys know about as much as I do.

Until we know more about Chip Kelly's plans....

The SI eval gets my attention because they start out by admitting that it's difficult to judge the draft without knowing what Kelly will do.

[hbionic]

Dio nails it. Can Dio get a bronze statue at the hall of CF'ers?

[reese125]

chip kelly is so mysterious.

[QB Eagles]

i agree with pretty much all that except the take on the barkley pick....first of all how could they say he will never start for them and secondly they traded a 7th rounder to move up three spots...how can you be mad at that....its basically as minimal a trade up as you can get

On the opposite side of stupidity, Les Bowen said:

Given the fact that the team traded up to be in position to take him, with a porous secondary still unaddressed in the draft, you'd have to think Barkley is Kelly's quarterback of the future.

Yeah by giving up that precious seventh rounder, they have little choice but to start Barkley.

[methdeez]

i agree with pretty much all that except the take on the barkley pick....first of all how could they say he will never start for them and secondly they traded a 7th rounder to move up three spots...how can you be mad at that....its basically as minimal a trade up as you can get

On the opposite side of stupidity, Les Bowen said:

Given the fact that the team traded up to be in position to take him, with a porous secondary still unaddressed in the draft, you'd have to think Barkley is Kelly's quarterback of the future.

Yeah by giving up that precious seventh rounder, they have little choice but to start Barkley.

It was a perfectly timed move, considering that 4 QBs come off the board then. If they hadn't traded up they probably would not have gotten him. He was the consensus best QB still on the board at that time.

[ice grillin you]

nm

[Rome]

http://www.philly.com/philly/blogs/dneagles/205650021.html

pretty balanced analysis from someone w/o a dog in the hunt.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Nice read and fair analysis

[ice grillin you]

its pretty much identical to mine but im a hater

[PhillyPhreak54]

Your Bennie Logan analysis is haterish.

[ice grillin you]

if he stinks he stinks...i can only go by what i see....the exec said his play didnt show much but hes a leader...sounds like the polite version of what i said....hes a vanilla guy who wont produce in the nfl imo....i think im also more harsh on him because of where he was chosen and the other directions they could have gone in...whereas the guy domo is interviewing is strictly evaluating the player not the pick

[PhillyPhreak54]

Well you gotta be about the player now. We can lament the fact that maybe Damontre Moore should've been the guy or someone else but this is who they've got. So either he balls out or crashes and burns.

I like his game because I like the well rounded DL who can anchor the run but push the pocket a bit. I think he will be a guy who is solid but not spectacular

He's better than some clown like Bryan Smith, Chris Gocong or whatever project they used to pick up and try to sell as some diamond in the rough.

[shorebird]

He's better than some clown like Bryan Smith, Chris Gocong or whatever project they used to pick up and try to sell as some diamond in the rough.

Ain't that the truth.