Which Would You Rather Have

[ice grillin you]

pleae dont be dumb and answer number 1 because "nfc east titles mean nothing"

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I answered #1 because NFC East titles mean nothing.  I hope that doesn't make me stupid.

But seriously, I'm not voting.  This is the worst poll in the history of and it's not even close.

[SD]

But seriously, I'm not voting.  This is the worst poll in the history of and it's not even close.

This one's close: http://www.concretefield.info/forum/index.php?topic=17134.0

[ice grillin you]

I answered #1 because NFC East titles mean nothing.  I hope that doesn't make me stupid.

But seriously, I'm not voting.  This is the worst poll in the history of and it's not even close.

so you think getting at least one guaranteed home nfl playoff game and a real chance at a superbowl run over getting a baseball player nine months before a hypothetical playoff run is the dumbest question ever

i personally take vick in the playoffs...over all the shtein that could happen in a 162 game plus playoffs baseball season

or are you saying you agree with me

either way if you think its a dumb question you dont talk sports much with the boys do you?

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

I'm saying that it's an idiotic hypothetical question, because Cliff Lee is already IN.  So, the choice is this:

A. Cliff Lee and a NFC East title
B. Cliff Lee and no NFC East title

In that case, I will take A.  Good?  Good.

[ice grillin you]

the whole point of the question is to say would you trade away getting cliff lee for the eagles to win the divison and get all that does and may come with it

the phils keep cliff lee and the eagles miss the playoffs

the phils dont get cliff lee but the eagles 100% win the nfc east

this isnt difficult stuff

[PoopyfaceMcGee]

So if I choose for them to trade him to allow the Eagles to win the division, would Amaro get good prospects this time?

[Tomahawk]

farg Cliff Lee

[ice grillin you]

damn son

[Tomahawk]

Not literally...he's a great pitcher and the Phillies probably have one of the best starting rotations of all time, but football is still much more important than baseball

[Sgt PSN]

It's good to have all this stupidity in one place. 

[phattymatty]

they should look into trading cliff lee.

[PhillyPhreak54]

Raped by MDS or Raped by Munson?

[Sgt PSN]

Raped by MDS or Raped by Munson?

I'd have to go with Munson.  MDS would likely fall in love once he got a taste of this and I don't need that type of drama.  Munson would just hit it and quit it.  Plus, he has a basement for this stuff.  I have no idea what type of accomadations Todd would have for me. 

[SD]

I'd go mds because there's a better chance munson has an std